By 1936 Phelan and Innis had been colleagues in Toronto for more than a decade. Since Innis — unlike McLuhan at this time — had no need of help to publish a paper, his Dalhousie Review piece must have appeared there through some kind of special request from the side of the Review. And this must have been mediated, if not originated, through Phelan. Whatever the details of the case may have been, it may be supposed that Phelan talked of Innis’ paper in the course of what must have been a great many exchanges with McLuhan about his Chesterton piece for Dalhousie Review and about his conversion (where Phelan played a, probably the, central role).
It is not impossible that Innis sought out a ‘remote’ publication for his rather acerbic essay. But if so, and if he thought Dalhousie Review appropriately remote, approach to Stewart would have taken place through Phelan. It is more likely, however, that the impetus came from the Review side and that Stewart and/or Phelan wanted a piece from UT’s rising star. But here again, Phelan was the natural person to approach Innis.