McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The vacuum tube, “the ballet of electrons”

it may interest you to know that the electron valve (…) represents a principle discovered in 1870 by Arthur Rimbaud and applied to poetry and painting since that time. Your account of the uses of the vacuum tube in heavy industry is an exact description of the poetic techniques of Joyce and Eliot in constructing their works. Their use of allusion as situational analogy effects an enormous amplification of power from small units, at the same time that it permits an unrivalled precision. Their stripping of rhetoric and statement corresponds to your observation that “it is no longer necessary to control a process at high-energy-levels by a mechanism in which the important details of control are carried out at these levels”. Stephane Mallarmé made this observation about his own poetic technique in 1885. In short, appearances and pedagogical limitations aside, there never is or can be a dichotomy between the top-level perceptions and procedures in the arts and sciences of an age. (McLuhan to Wiener, March 28, 1951)

The idea that “there never is or can be a dichotomy between the top-level perceptions and procedures in the arts and sciences of an age” was central to the work of Sigfried Giedion whom McLuhan met in 1943, initiating a decades-long correspondence between the two. His own background as an engineering student in 1928 at the University of Manitoba who transferred to English and Philosophy might be thought to prefigure this notion. His letter to Innis in March 1951 ends with a statement of the notion and then concludes with reference to AM and FM radios in which the vacuum tube was an essential component: “the actual techniques of (political-)economic study today (Innis was chair of the political economocs department) seem to me to be of genuine relevance to anybody who wishes to grasp the best in current poetry and music. And vice versa. There is a real, living unity in our time, as in any other, but it lies submerged under a superficial hubbub of sensation. Using Frequency Modulation techniques one can slice accurately through such interference, whereas Amplitude Modulation leaves you bouncing on all the currents” (Letters, 223).