McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

GV and TT p22 — Commentary 3: “McLuhan is a charlatan”

A month later Quigley followed up this review with a letter to the Washington Post (October 20, 1968) titled ‘One page of McLuhan’ Here he stated for the record that “McLuhan is a charlatan” and made his case for this charge by fact-checking that “one page of McLuhan”. Quigley showed in his letter (and in less detailed fashion also in his review) that page 25 of War and Peace in the Global Village is full of assertions which are either false on their face or are at least highly questionable (though presented by McLuhan in his usual never-in-doubt fashion). He then asked:

Quigley’s review is given on the same page of the website referenced in the post above. A link there goes to a scan of the original.